I was watching Robot Chicken the other night when my lady love brought up how disgusting\disturbing she thought the show was with all of the violence and whatnot. [Shakes head …I think I was just channeling Dr. Christopher Turk for a second there]
Today I asked her how that show was different from the cartoons we grew up watching. Wily E. Coyote suffered far worse at the hands of his own ineptitude, and the high manufacturing and quality control standards of the (obviously based in China) ACME corporation. Tom Cat was cut up and lacerated in far more ways than the most diabolical sushi chef could have ever imagined; not too mention suffering through levels of blunt force trauma that would make the boys that play with the supercollider envious. Do we even have to bring up the indignities that Elmer J. Fudd suffered at the hands, errr…I mean to say paws, of our favorite cross dressing member of the Leporidae family. Her response to my query was “I don’t know…. It’s just different” I of course respect her opinion but have a hard time seeing why she feels that way. Granted, the gore is a bit more pronounced on R.C. but I think red play dough looks just like red play dough, even when it is squirting out of a Rocky Balboa action figure’s eye socket. I, in many ways, find this much more cartoonish than a shotgun blast to a ducks face or Tom getting his tail stuck in the chop-o-matic. In the cartoon the gore is self and medium consistent, and therefore more realistic. Whereas the stop action animated play dough gore just looks silly ”bleeding” out of a plastic toy. To me it’s more reminiscent of when Stretch Armstrong sprung a leak, than of various viscera.
As I sit here typing, the thought occurs to me that in the case of R.C., it may just be that I am male and she is female, and as children we played with our toys in drastically different ways. I realize that the things that the characters on R.C. do to each other,albeit with significantly more sarcasm and cynicism, are the same things that little boys have been imagining when they are playing with their action figures since before G.I. Joe was in basic training. I have watched a friend’s granddaughter play with her dolls (yes, boys have action figures, girls have dolls) and I don’t recall ever hearing Dora scream out in pain because Thomas the tank engine ran over her at the behest of the Dark Lord of the Sith. In point of fact I think the train said “excuses me please” on that particular afternoon, and as I recollect, Darth Vader was no where to be seen. I do on the other hand, remember my friends and me conceiving, and acting out things with our star wars figures that would have made Torquemada wince, then give full points for style and originality. Nothing can surpass little boys sheer capacity for creative fiendishness; to quote a certain excessively rotund, dead, movie icon “The horror, the horror…”
(Big lit nerd points if you can remember who originally made that pronouncement and in what book. Don't cheat and Google it ya' filthy heathen) Maybe this is the appeal of R.C. it’s like playing with our toys allover again, except this time the production values are slightly higher.
So what’s your take on the issue?